The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit ruled recently that Alice Corporation’s computerized platform for reducing risk in financial trading is an abstract concept that is ineligible for patent protection.

Bill Atkins, an IP partner based in Pillsbury’s Northern Virginia and Washington, D.C. offices, spoke to Law360 about what the CLS Bank International v. Alice Corp. Pty. Ltd. ruling means for patent law.

“This decision is most unfortunate. It reflects poorly on the inability of our Federal Circuit to provide useful and cohesive guidance to patent holders/applicants and potential infringers and those who counsel them,” he said. “It also reveals the apparent divisiveness within the court. But, perhaps most importantly, it kicks the can up to the Supreme Court for a decision when the Federal Circuit was created to reconcile issues such as this one.”